I
have a KDX 200 and my rear shock spring is way too soft. My dealer wants
almost 100 bucks for a heavier spring. Is there anything I can do to
stiffen the rear end without popping for the hundred? Thank you.
Joe
Average
I
have a 1987 Ford F-150 set up for fun off-roading, but the front end is
way too soft on the bumps. I checked on heavier (stronger) springs, but
can't afford them. Is there anything I can do?
John
Average (Joe's brother)
These mythical
letters are actually representative of many we've received. The problem is
not isolated to the KDX enduro bike, or the popular Ford trucks. Nope.
Just about any rider or driver who rides/drives aggressively will find out
that the standard spring(s) that came on the bike/truck are just not beefy
enough.
To
get our new spring rate, we cut the coil of the spring off at this
point. |
For
maximum safety, hang the spring over a bucket filled with water
before torching off the unwanted coil(s). |
The
newly cut top coil should now be heated to a dull red and gently
bent down before grinding it flat. |
That
new top coil should now be ground flat to sit in the mounting just
like the original spring shape. |
Here
you go: one completed spring that's stronger than stock, ready to
be mounted. |
The
dead (or inactive) coils are those that touch at both ends when
mounted. |
Here's
the basic info needed to determine spring rate. |
A
number of factors determine the actual rate of the spring,
including the diameter of the coils. |
You
should also measure the thickness of the coil wire itself. |
The information you
see here is based on a single-shock dirt bike, but applies to most any
coil spring, whether it's used on a truck, SUV, or buggy.
The owner of a new
bike will often not notice that his spring is too soft at first, because
of the sensation of a fresh, tight new bike and the attendant careful
riding. However, once he gets the unit broken in and scratched up a few
times he may find himself resorting to the preload adjustment rings.
And, no matter what
his owner's manual states, increasing the preload will not keep the shock
from bottoming out under hard riding conditions. The answer, of course, is
a heavier spring. Naturally, the correct amount of sag in the rear end and
reasonable amounts of preload will have substantial effects on the action
of the rear end, but it's possible to have the right amount of sag for the
rear suspension and still have a too soft spring.
MODIFY YOUR OWN
SPRING
Let's say you've exhausted all the normal preload and have, in fact,
determined that your spring is too soft. You can avoid spending anywhere
from 75 dollars to well over a hundred for a shock spring and equivalent
bucks for fork springs. Yes, this low-bucks approach to customizing your
springs works on the fork springs, as well.
You're going to need
access to a set of torches and a decent bench grinder to get the job done
right. First, here's how the procedure is done, then we'll show you how to
calculate just how much you want to cut off your spring to increase the
stiffness.
WAIT A MINUTE!
HOW CAN CUTTING A SPRING MAKE IT STRONGER?
Gotcha, didn't we. You see, a number of things determine the rate of a
spring, among them the thickness of the wire, the diameter of the coils
(to their centerline) and the number of active coils. As a rule of thumb,
the fewer active coils, the higher the spring rate-all other things being
equal.
Since we can't
change the thickness of the wire, or the diameter, this leaves the number
of active coils as the only variable we have control over.
Dead coils are those
at each end of the spring that make contact with something.
If you have a spring
with, say, ten coils, then two of them are dead (inactive) and eight of
them are live (active) coils. But enough theory for now. Let's get back to
the actual operation of making our springs stronger.
STEP-BY-STEP
SPRING MODIFICATION
Once you've determined just how much you need to cut off your spring to
make it stiffer, here's the procedure. Put some water in a bucket and lay
the spring over the edge. Not only will this make a solid holder for the
spring, but it will give the hot coils and sparks a very safe place in
which to drown themselves out.
A mark should be
scribed on the coil where the cut is to be made. Heat up the coil with a
normal welding tip until it's cherry red and just starting to turn yellow.
When the metal starts to puddle or melt, turn off the acetylene. The
oxygen will feed the hot spot and the wire will literally burn.
At this point, you
are merely feeding oxygen to an existing point of combustion. The wire is
actually burning! Of course, you can simply take a cutting torch and blaze
it off, but this technique is much cleaner and very easy to master. You
might experiment with a scrap piece of metal first to get the feel.
Next, place the
shortened spring firmly on a flat surface or in a sturdy vise. Then start
heating the top coil about an inch from the freshly cut end, very slowly.
Do not overheat it. Once it turns cherry red, you can squeeze it gently
together with a sturdy set of pliers.
The key here is
gentle pressure. If you force it too much, there's a chance that you'll
crack the spring and render it useless. Remember, easy pressure and fairly
low heat-just enough to let the coil start to sag under a light squeeze.
After the first part
of the coil has been bent down a bit, back up another inch and heat some
more, then gently put additional pressure on the coil. After a few minutes
of coaxing and sensible use of the torch, the top (freshly cut) coil will
be flattened out to the approximate desired shape.
Now you have to
flatten it so it'll fit flush against the top (or bottom) of the shock.
A grinder is
essential. You probably won't have access to one as strong as the one we
used here at Works Performance, but the job can be done with a bench
grinder. Plan on taking about a half hour of work with the average home
bench grinder. You can also take the shock spring to almost any machine
shop and talk the guy into surfacing it for you for a few bucks.
One word of caution:
After you heat and bend the top coil, do not quench it in water to cool it
down too quickly or you might make the spring take a set. Wait a few
minutes until all the color has disappeared from the spring. Your spring
is now ready to be sanded clean and repainted. And, if your calculations
were correct, you would now have the new heavier spring rate you were
after, at no cost to you.
HOW TO FIGURE OUT
HOW MUCH TO CUT OFF
First off, you should know what the rate of the spring you're using is.
That's easy enough. All springs are coded in some fashion and the owner's
manual tells you what the different springs are. Some use a grind mark,
while others use paint to identify the rate.
Let's say you're
starting out with a 600-pound shock spring. If your shock is too soft, a
ten-percent increase in poundage would be a logical place to start.
You have to take the
rate of the spring (600 pounds) times the number of active coils (in this
case, 8.875 coils) and divide this by the desired rate. Sounds like tough
math, but it isn't. Here's how it looks on paper:
600
pounds times 8.875 active coils = 5325.000
Now, take this
number and divide it by the rate you want, which in our case is a
ten-percent increase, or a rate of 660 pounds. On paper, again, here's the
story:
5325
divided by 660 = 8.0682
This leaves you with
the magic number of 8.0682, which is the number of active coils that will
give you a 660-pound spring. Pretty neat, eh? In our spring, that means
that we would have to cut off 7/8 of one full coil to get what we were
after.
Once again: It's
only the active coils that count. So, out with the torch, zap on the
grinder, and 7/8 of a coil later, you have your 660-pound spring.
WORDS OF WARNING
Don't get in over your head. And don't try to ask a spring to do too much.
One of the things you must watch out for is coil bind. A spring should
never be forced to bottom out against itself.
If, for example, you
have five inches of available spring movement and the shock travels 4-1/2
inches, it's clear that you should cut no more than half an inch off that
particular spring.
It's not too
difficult to calculate just how much available spring travel you have in
any spring. Merely measure the thickness of the wire, count the number of
coils and then measure the space between the coils and count the number of
spaces. Basic math.
SPRING RATES EVEN
YOU CAN UNDERSTAND
A typical straight-rate spring is a very easy animal to understand. Let's
say you have a 100-pound spring. This means that when the spring is
compressed one full inch, it'll have 100 pounds of force.
If you did this one
inch of compression on a bathroom scale, the scale would read 100 pounds.
When the spring is compressed two inches, it'll read 200 pounds, at three
inches, 300 pounds-and so forth. Of course, there are progressive springs,
but the math on them is complex.
PRELOAD,
CONFUSING THE ISSUE
Preload is close to black magic to many. Let's go back to that 100-pound
spring we were talking about. If you added 1/4-inch of preload to that
spring, the first inch of travel would yield 125 pounds of force. One-half
inch of preload would bring it up to 150 pounds, and so on.
However, preload
affects only the first inch of travel. After the first inch of travel, the
spring will still gain only 100 pounds with each additional inch of
travel, no matter how much the preload. This is where a lot of people blow
it. Ideally, a light preload will let the wheel react to small bumps
properly. Way too much preload will make the finest shock (or forks) feel
miserable on the small bumps, then the suspension will still wallow
through the mid- stroke.
CAN I DO THE SAME
BASIC STUFF TO FORK SPRINGS?
Of course you can. You just have a much longer spring and may have to
count a lot more when you add up the active coils. Let's assume you have
an 18-pound fork spring and you feel that it's too soft. Your calculations
show that if you cut off three coils, you'll end up with a 20-pound fork
spring, which is what you want.
Fine. Go for it. But
make sure that you make up the space you take away. If you cut off two
inches of fork spring, you must replace those two inches with some sort of
a spacer. If not, the forks will tend to sag and dive too much from lack
of proper preload.
The same, naturally,
is true of the rear. If you don't have enough threaded area in your shock
body to make up for the removed coil area, you will have to fabricate a
simple spacer to take up the room.
MYTH DESTRUCTION
FOR YOUR AMUSEMENT
Some years ago, several companies offered "booster" springs for
forks. These were said to stiffen up the stock fork springs and make the
forks work better. Hundreds were sold, most often to owners of Japanese
dirt bikes.
Think about this for
a moment If you had a set of 20-pound fork springs and then added a
100-pound "booster" spring on top of them, in effect you would
be softening the actual spring rate. Preposterous, you say? Impossible?
Not really
The formula for
figuring out rates with double springs is as follows: Take the individual
rates multiplied and divide them by the individual rates added. Therefore,
we have 100 x 20 ? 120, or an actual spring rate of 16.6 pounds.
Obviously, the
initial feel of the forks would be stiffer, but only because of greatly
increased preload. The mid-stroke rate would actually be less than with
the stock spring. There would be a slight gain in resistance to bottoming
out with this setup, as the oil level would be raised a bit.
HELPFUL HINTS AND
COMMON SENSE
You might run into kg readings instead of pounds when you check your owner
s manual. Do not be intimidated. Should you want to change them into
something real 'Mericans understand, merely take the number and multiply
it by 56 pounds. For example, you have a 7.9 kg spring: 7.9 x 56pounds =
442.4 pounds.
Ideally, your spring
should be matched to your damper. And the correct word is damper, not
dampener. If you run a horribly heavy spring that the shock is not capable
of controlling, then you'll have a rear suspension that'll bounce around
like a basketball every time it recoils from a bump
When you do increase
your spring rate, you should also (normally) increase your rebound
damping. Most modern shocks have some sort of adjustment that will let you
change the rebound settings
To increase the
rebound on forks it may be necessary to go to a heavier fork oil, as not
all forks have adjustable rebound.
Here's a great
formula to have handy if you want to calculate the rate of a spring when
you don't know the rate:
RATE 11.5 x Wire
Diameter to the fourth power (D4) ? by 8 x Number of Active Coils x Mean
Diameter cubed.
You won't be doing
this between rounds of the TV boxing match Better you should look it up in
your manual.
Special
thanks to Works Performance Products, (818) 701-1010, for tech advice and
guidance. These guys make great bike shocks for any machine.
|